On the hill east of the Church is the old Sharpsburg cemetery. It has been vandalized, invaded by livestock, and overgrown with sprouts as Mother Nature seeks to reclaim the land. Tradition has it that an Indian was the first to be buried the the cemetery but cause of death is unknown. The settlers had a good relationship with the few Indians in the area so possibly he died from natural causes. Many of the names that are in the old cemetery are no longer a part of the community. There were few doctors and epidemics of consumption (TB), diphtheria, cholera, and influenza sometimes ravaged the community. Known burials are listed below and there are probably many others whose graves were poorly marked or had markers made of limestone or wood which have disappeared.
Sharpsburg Cemetery
BURDITT: Mary Jane 23 Feb 1823-10 Jul 1901 nee Burditt
James Augustus 26 Nov 1820-9 Nov 1906
BURDITT: Sarah E. d/o JA & MJ Burditt, 1 Feb 1859-20 Apr 1869
Lutie Bailey her sister 12 May 1864-27 May 1878
BURDITT: Lucy Ann 15 Jan 1830-1 Nov 1907 nee Musgrove
Lewis C 2 Jul 1826-10 Oct 1903
BURDITT: William T. 22 Jan 1886-23 Sep 1887
Joshua D. 13 Apr 1869-1 Oct 1887
BURDITT: Lucy w/o Tompkins 22 Jan 1802-20 Feb 1385 nee Burditt
Tompkins 3 Aug 1783-7 Nov 1855
BURDITT: Eivira 1848-1878
John L. 10 Sep 1846-19 Sep 1927
BURDITT: Thomas 1813-10 Sep 1884
nee See
Sarah A. w/o Thomas 27 Aug 1821-28 Oct 1875
BURDITT: Infant dau LC & LA 27 Jul 1855
James Bailey s/o LC & LA 27 Sep 1859-24 Jul 36
BURDITT: Doctor Morrison 28 Jan 1799-1381
Mash (child) 19 Jun 1894 k/o Frank
BURDITT: David Buchanan
JACKSON: Fannie M
Edwin A.
JACKSON: Edwin A. 17 Mar.1861-22 Nov 1932
Ida Mae 3 May 1867-1959 (Burditt)
JACKSON: Emily E consort of Wm. P 2 May 1849 Age 23-7-14
William 5 Oct 1846 Age 27 yr 7 da.
JACKSON: James W. 24 Nov 1824-28 Feb 1881
Sarah E. 25 May 1828-15 Dec 1910 Mary E. F. their dau. 29 Sep 1854 Age 1-0-15
VANCE: J.D. s/o JH & EL 14 Jul 1902-4 Sep 1908
TULLY: William 1851-
Mary Theodocia his wife 15 Jun 1857-3 Mar 1928
BOWER: Mary A. w/o Jacob Jr. 6 Dec 1872 Age 38-4-11
BUCHANAN: H.M. 24 May 1833-17 Aug 1866
D. J. M. 19 Jul 1865 Age 55-2-26
STAGE: Talitha C. w/o David 20 Feb 1872 Age 29
BOULWARE: Benjamin W. s/o Wm & A. 22 Mar 1851 Age 17 mo 29 day
L. J. R.: Died Sep 1843 ???
DAVIS: Edward Stephen s/o S & LM 29 Oct 1863-12 Mar 1865 Thomas 2O Apr 1357 Age 56
Joseph 12 Feb 1870 Age 67
FREEMAN: Jane 14 Feb 1366 Age 65
Lewis D. 29 Feb 1880 Age 82
WARNER: Samuel 13 Jan 1879 Age 70-2-25
MESNER: Amanda B. w/o Rev. J. F. 17 Apr 1873 Age 22-7-15
COUCH: Sarah A 24 Nov 1877-28 Sep 1880 Children of PH & MR
Charles T. 15 Dec 1879-19 Oct 1880
SEE: Henry H. 10 May 1818-30 Jul 1831
WILLIAMS: Elizabeth R. (Sharpe) w/o Spotswood S. Born Albemarle Co VA 9 Aug 1812 married OldhamCo KY 2 Oct 1831 Died I Aug 1873
WILLIAMS: Spotswood S. Born VA 12 Mar 1805. To Marion Co 1840 Millwright by trade. Died 22 Jan 1886
RANDOL: Ida F. d/o JB & MA 26 Mar Oct 1879
WILLIAMS: Eveline d/o SS & ER -14 Apr 1851 Age 1-6-10 Infant s/o SS & ER 18 Nov 1857-28 Nov 1357
MEFFORD: Ella M. d/o H & AE 19 Mar 1851-8 Oct 1851
BROWN: Earl 1875-1923
BUSH: Ray Gene 1923-1923
BUSH: Neppie L 26 Dec 1882-31 Aug 1935 d/o John W & Sarah
James S. 3 Jun 1877-8 Aug 1959 Burditt
KELLY: Eliza J 12 Jan 1865 Age 2-9-26) d/o J & C
Emma A. 12 Jan 1865 of 1-1-3
SPARKS: Orson 9 Jul 1792-15 May 1370
Margaret G. Oct 1793-9 Jan 1880 d/o Wm & Elizabeth
WILLIAMS: Arabella d 30 Jul 1837 Age 35 Burditt s/o AG & WW
JACKSON: ch/o Ed & Ida M 2 Dec 1890 ch/o Ed & Ida M 4 Jul 1901 6 da
SHARP: John R.B. 19 May 1892 Age 32-1-8 Lucy J. 10 Jul 1881 23-4-2
SHARP: James R. s/o JR & SE 6 Feb 1857 Age 1-4-14
William L. 6 Feb 1857 Age 3-11-19
SHARP: Rev. Thomas P. 6-Jan 1871 Age 71
J. T. 13 Aug 1872 Age 47-10-11
s/o JA & EF 7 Sep 1852 Age 10 mo 2 da
SHARP- Robert E.
SHARP: Rev. Richard b Albemarle Co VA 11 May 1787-4 Feb 1850
Mary S. Consort of Richard 4 Nov 1850 Age 60
MUSGROVE: Lewis W. s/o Wm & SE 4 Jul 1890-23 Aug 1911
MUSGROVE: William-1859-1919
Sarah E. w/o Wm 7 Nov 1861-9 Aug 1924 nee Musgrove
RUCKER: Elizabeth Ellen d/o AG & TM 4 Aug 1848 10 mo 14 da
Eliza J. 15 Jun 1852 Age 1-2-25
her sister Sarah F. 15 Mar 1853 Age 12 yr 12 da
RUCKER: Andrew M. s/o WA & SE 10 Aug 1871-24 Dec 1871
RUBISON: Easther E. d/o John & Jane I Feb 1838-7 Apr 1841
John W. her brother 22 Nov 1821-7 Mar 1835
RUBISON: George W. 1844-1876
B. Franklin 1835-1894
HAYDEN: James P. died Feb 1909 Age 55 g/son Richard Sharp
SPARKS: Jane A 6 Jan 1883 w/o J.W. age 54
HAYDEN: Susan 1903
TULLY: M.J. Morrow 29 May 1915 d/o Wm.
This was a United Methodist Church not a Baptist. I know…I’m a former member.